Select Page

Book Review: Pumpkinheads

by | Oct 4, 2020 | Books

Spread the love

Pumpkinheads was the first graphic novel I ever read. I was familiar with Rainbow Rowell’s writing from a previous book I read: Fangirl. I was a big fan of Fangirl and I have other books from Rowell in my TBR (to-be-read) pile. With Rowell’s stellar writing and [Erin Faith Hick’s gorgeous illustrations, Pumpkinheads is the perfect fall read.

Pumpkinheads takes place during one of my favorite seasons: fall. Fall was one of my favorite seasons growing up because it meant that apples were being harvested. My dad is a 4th generation farmer, and apples are one of the crops that he grows. Pumpkinheads also takes place on a farm, but they specialize in what’s called agritourism, which means planning activities or attractions that bring people to a farm or ranch.

The story focuses on two high school seniors who are working their final shift at a pumpkin farm: Deja and Josiah (Josie). They’ve been working together at the farm for three years, and on their final day, they decide to explore the pumpkin patch and find the “Fudge Girl” so Josie can ask her out on a date. As they go through the farm to find her, they visit the different attractions and meet up with their coworkers. Deja and Josie make an adorable pair of friends that both compliment each other and challenge each other to be their very best.

I wanted to include it in my PopSugar Reading Challenge, where I read 50 books for the calendar year based on the prompts I’m given. You can use this book for the following prompts:

– a book that won an award in 2019 (the prompt I chose)

(Goodreads Best Books of 2019 – Graphic Novel & Comics)- a book with a map- a book with at least four stars on Goodreads- a book published the month of your birthday (August)

This is the perfect book for autumn. There’s an added element of suspense as the book progresses and it gets closer to closing time at the pumpkin patch while Josie and Deja are still trying to find “Fudge Girl.” My only gripe was that Josie’s character wasn’t portrayed as two-dimensional as Deja’s character. While Deja wasn’t the main focus of the story, her personality didn’t take over the story. I also appreciated how Rowell and Hicks wrote Deja as a bi-sexual African American teenager; it was nice to see that kind of representation. If you’re looking for a fall-themed book that you can read in one sitting, I recommend reading “Pumpkinheads.”

test alt text

You May Also Like…

Book Review: The Sun Down Motel

Book Review: The Sun Down Motel

Two of my favorite topics for the podcasts I listen to are true crime and the supernatural. Usually, if a place has a history of death or terrible events, it tends to attract the supernatural. It’s not often that the supernatural and true crime get mixed, and author...

Books I’m Re-Reading in 2021

Books I’m Re-Reading in 2021

When I started reading again for fun, I didn't think about including books I read before would be as fulfilling. Boy was I wrong. Adding books that I've read before helped me complete numerous reading challenges in 2020. I ended up re-reading seven books in 2020, and...


  1. iris findlay

    I’ll have to check that out! Looks very cute.

  2. Megan

    Ooooh, I love graphic novels. Have you read “They Called Us Enemy” by George Takei (yes, that George Takei!) It’s an amazing story about the Japanese internment camps in the US during WWII. Definitely recommend.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jenn & Tonic

Lifestyle blogger and digital marketer based in Wisconsin. Michigander at heart. I'm here to provide my take on life through my blog. Fueled by chardonnay, cast recordings and chocolate.